Skip to content


Will Amex eventually force Square to abandon the blended rate like they did with PayPal?

From my recent post to this question on Quora.

American Express has always charged higher merchant interchange rates than Visa, MasterCard and Discover. They justify these rates to merchants by claiming to have a higher end card holder base that spends more money with retailers and is, therefore, worth more to the retailer.

PayPal pioneered the simple blended interchange cost structure for merchant accounts. The theory was that merchant fees were excessively complicated and unfriendly to merchants, with different rates for different categories of goods of services or different card types, etc. PayPal took the merchant friendly route and offered merchants a simple to understand blended fee structure. It is a much more merchant friendly form of pricing, hands down.

The problem with PayPal’s simple blended average pricing for Amex was that it undercut Amex’s pricing in the market. It became cheaper to accept Amex through your PayPal account than it was to go direct to Amex. This was obviously an issue for the Amex merchant sales team. So. Amex went back to PayPal and required them to break Amex out of their blended pricing structure. This was a multi year negotiation, as you can imagine.
PayPal’s marketing materials now have the following footnote on pricing: “2 This fee applies to Visa, MasterCard, and Discover transactions. American Express transaction fees are 3.5% + $0.00 USD EA. effective July 13, 2010 for new merchants and October 25, 2010 for existing merchants.”

With respect to Square, they are positioned exactly like PayPal. Their merchant friendly simple blended pricing for card present transactions is below what you would be charged directly from Amex. I think it is reasonable to assume that Amex will ultimately go back to Square and take issue with their pricing model.

Timing is another thing, however. PayPal didn’t ultimately break out Amex pricing until they were at a total payment volume of >$50B / year. So, Square likely has some time to figure this out.

Posted in Payments, Uncategorized.

Tagged with , , .


PayPal Acquires Zong, mCommerce Payments Combination That Will be Tough to Beat

PayPal today announced that it has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Zong, the mobile carrier-billing leader, for approximately $240 million in cash.  This is a strategic move for PayPal, designed to deepen its leadership in eCommerce payments and further define it as a major player in mobile payments.

When I left PayPal in late 2008 to become a venture capitalist, I focused much of my attention on finding innovative companies in the financial services space.  Zong is the first investment I made in the category.  At the time, it was being spun out of a mobile content company and looking for a Series A investor to help it become a mobile payment leader.  It was clear to me then that Zong was building a payment network that was highly complementary to what I had helped build at PayPal and would be strategically valuable in shaping the future of mCommerce.

Synergies Start with Digital Goods

Mobile Carrier Billed payments systems, where Zong is the clear leader, have almost solely existed in the digital/virtual goods world. Most of the world’s largest digital good platforms derive 15-50% of their payment volume through mobile carrier billing systems and more than 70% when purchases are initiated on a handset.  These systems reduce friction in the payment flow (i.e. fewer clicks) and expand addressable markets to the billions of consumers with mobile phones, but no bank card.  This incremental volume, while at a higher cost of payment, has become foundational for most digital good merchants.

While PayPal has done a nice job of serving digital good merchants, the addition of a mobile payment option will significantly increase PayPal’s relevance in this important category.

Securing Leadership in mCommerce Payments

One of the most notable trends emerging from the rise of smartphones is the dramatic shift of eCommerce volume from the web browser to the mobile browser/mobile app.  Gilt Groupe has publically stated that more than 10% of its explosive gross merchandise sales are now coming through mobile devices.  Similarly, its has been rumored that nearly 20% of Groupon’s gross merchandise sales are originated on mobile devices.  PayPal, in fact, just a few weeks ago announced that it expected $3B of its total payment volume to occur on mobile devices in 2011.  Given these early data points, I would guess that more than 25% of eCommerce will occur on mobile devices by 2015, strongly ahead of what many analysts are predicting.

As mobile commerce soars, the friction that the standard checkout flow entails will simply break down.  Entering Bill-To, Ship-To and Payment Info on a mobile device doesn’t work.  Consumers will need a seamless process and merchants will require checkouts that offer equal or better conversion rates than they’ve experienced on the web.  Herein lies an opportunity for PayPal to create a single universal checkout for the mobile web.  A wallet in the cloud.  With the addition of Zong to the PayPal family of services, PayPal increases its set of assets that aid in delivering the best mCommerce checkout experience.  Zong brings PayPal millions of authenticated mobile phones to its user base, carrier billing as a form of payment in the wallet, existing mobile payment checkout APIs for Android and Mobile Web, and a team that has been 100% focused on building best of breed mobile payment experiences for the last several years.

Scale Advantages That Benefit Everyone

Many entrepreneurs I meet that are building new payments related businesses underestimate the complexity they have in front of them.  At its core, payment businesses require expertise in risk management, payment operations (connections to hundreds of banks, mobile carriers and intermediaries) and consumer servicing.  I’ve often said that PayPal is actually a “risk management company” more than it is a “payments company”.

While Zong has executed well in all of these areas and recruited top talent with deep domain expertise, the combination with PayPal will improve the quality and cost of service for Zong’s consumers, merchants and mobile carrier partners.

Overall, I think this is a very smart acquisition by the PayPal team.  Hats off to PayPal President Scott Thompson for having the strategic conviction.  It will also mark an exciting new chapter for the Zong team.  I will miss my nearly daily interaction with the Zong team, but couldn’t be happier that I could help bring these teams together and I look forward to watching PayPal continue its incredible success record.

Official PayPal Blog post on the transaction is here.

Posted in Payments.


Another Matrix Partners’ blog

Two years in the venture capitalist seat here at Matrix Partner and it has become clear that I need to start a blog.  Lots to say and 140 characters just isn’t getting the job done.  Hopefully someone listens :-)

This will be the fourth blog among my business partners.  David Skok has the best in class blog dedicated to sales and marketing strategies for SAAS businesses…a topic David and I spend lots of time talking about.  Josh Hannah, another one of the serial entrepreneurs among the team here, covers a broad base of topics on venture and startups.  Antonio Rodriguez, the true hacker among us, also blogs about a broad base of topics but with more of a rant tone to it.

Onward we go.  Another VC / Startup blog…

Posted in Venture Capital.